2014 ISL & NEPSAC Hugh Caldera Bowl Champions
2015 ISL & NEPSAC Wayne Sanborn Bowl Champions
2016 ISL Champions
2017 ISL & NEPSAC Kevin Fleming Bowl Champions
Lawrence Academy competes in the 16-team Independent School League (ISL), which consists of selective college preparatory schools in and around the greater Boston area from as far north as Concord, NH, and as far south as Newport, RI. All ISL schools are members of NEPSAC, the New England Private School Athletic Council, which governs all interscholastic play for independent schools in the Northeast.